Tuesday, May 22, 2012

Facebook comments:

5 Responses to “China, Inc.: How the Rise of the Next Superpower Challenges America and the World”

  1. I haven’t actually read the book, but the title says it all…the author doesn’t understand economics!

    Wealth is made by the ingenuity of the people who seek to produce better goods and services that would satisfy consumer demand.

    Ingenuity is sadly lacking in China, now, or ever. Look at any Chinese invention, and see its real development only when the Europeans got hold of it, from razor blades to paper money.

    Not convinced, look at patent production in China. It is eclipsed by most US states or European nations.

    Sorry, no sale.
    Rating: 1 / 5

  2. L. Doyle says:

    This is the typical China will rise up and dominate the earth book.

    It sounds a awful lot like the Japan will rise up and dominate the books of the 1980′s. In fact, one was even named “Japan, Inc.”

    My question to Mr. Fishman is this: Where is Japan now?
    Rating: 1 / 5

  3. Tan says:

    read the “Nine Commentaries on the Communist Party” – at http://www.english.epochtimes.com. A series of articles that explores the history of the CCP; first published in the Epoch Times – the most widely distributed Chinese language newspaper in the world. Since its publication in November 2004, over 2 million people have resigned from the CCP.
    Rating: 3 / 5

  4. M. Shih says:

    So with all due respect:

    1) If China is so bad, don’t do business there, no one is forcing you

    2) All American CEO who deals with China are unpatriotic Americans

    3) All American CEO who outsource to China and India are immoral capitalist

    4) All American CEO who deal with China should pay a fine or go to Jail. -But they are not! And as matter of facts, they are getting big bonuses.

    5) Don’t blame the Chinese, they are providing a service (cheap) but American consumers and executives are the ones knocking on their doors.

    6) You can’t have both ways; you can’t try to use cheap labor in 3rd world countries and then turn around and point fingers at the people you are doing business with.

    7) Stop bringing up the WWII theory on some of these comments, just because the USA fought and won WWI -which is GREAT! It does not mean the USA is correct FOREVER…common sense.

    Rating: 1 / 5

  5. I was going to write a long review but the other two reviewers below already summarized my thoughts nicely.

    I will second McDaniel on China’s ticking “Greybeards Bomb” (China has a old population, because of their one-child policy) and second Chiang on the accounting tricks with nominal versus ppp.

    Noted academians have found China’s GDP is about the size of Italy or at most Italy plus France. This is based on the amount of oil they consume. Oil prices have gone up because oil supplies are historically always tight unless Saudi Arabia acts as swing producer–even the slightest increase in consumption will increase the price. Blame it on China? Not necessarily. When India starts to grow like China the same thing will happen.

    BTW, “India, Inc.: How the Rise of the Next Superpower Challenges America and the World” should be the next book we read–not only do they speak English, but their population is much younger than China’s.

    I second these reviews:

    Reviewer: David Chiang (New Jersey, United States) –

    Reviewer: Michael P. Mcdaniel (Oklahoma City, Oklahoma United States) –
    Rating: 1 / 5

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Related Posts