Tuesday, May 22, 2012

Facebook comments:

5 Responses to “Beijing and Shanghai”

  1. R. HUANG says:

    The only thing good about this guide is its comprehensive road listing in the back of the Beijing and Shanghai sections. The best guide for a solid experience is Luxe’s various City Guides–the one for Shanghai is bomb. This guide is for boring people who have boring lives.
    Rating: 1 / 5

  2. S. Kelly says:

    I brought this travel guide with me to Beijing and Shanghai and in general thought it was useful and well-written. Unfortunately, the tiny serifed typeface was just too small for me to read easily. Not a problem for many people, but it sure was for me. I thought most of the information was accurate and helpful. I did not like the way they organized the book by mixing Beijing and Shanghai–I went to Beijing and wanted all that information and then I went to Shanghai and wanted all that info. I had to watch the color coding and page information to be sure I didn’t wander into the wrong city (not in real life, only in the pages of the guide). It was a little heavier than I expected and I would be willing to sacrifice some of the high quality pictures and paper in order to make it lighter. Even considering the things I didn’t like about the book, I would still buy it since the info was solid.
    Rating: 3 / 5

  3. l2 says:

    Like all DK books, this one is very glossy and colorful. If you’re going on a packaged tour of these cities, this is a fine book to have. It has nice photos and maps of the major tourist attractions, as well as some historical information and suggested walking tours. On the other hand, if you’re going to be visiting these cities for an extended period, you will probably exhaust the information in this slim book pretty quickly.

    If you’re a backpacker or independent tourist, this book will have limited value to you as there are only a handful of hotel and restaurant suggestions. The DK books are published much less frequently than other guidebooks, so I suppose extensive listings (like you find in annually updated guidebooks) would be obsolete a couple of years later.

    This book does have a 2009 publication date and the Beijing subway map does include the new routes that were added for the 2008 Olympics.
    Rating: 4 / 5

  4. I waited for the new version to be released and found it very lacking. It was too high level to provide any real value. I ended up leaving the book at the hotel and used my friend’s Lonely Planet. I did hear great reviews about 10 Top Places to See (or something like that) by Eye Witness.
    Rating: 2 / 5

  5. Uncle Ed says:

    I recently took a trip to China which included Beijing and Shanghai. I found the guide to be outstanding. A number of the people on the tour also had this guide, and I heard several comments on how good it was.
    Rating: 5 / 5

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Related Posts